TOWN OF MARBLETOWN PLANNING BOARD MINUTES

Date: May 15, 2014

Download these minutes:  061114 PB MINUTES FINAL

Chairman Lanzarone opened the meeting at 7:30pm.

Town of Marbletown Town Hall, 3775 Main Street, Stone Ridge, NY 12484

 

 

Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Steve Wood Absent
Sylvia Ricci Present
Todd Natale Present
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Present
Kristopher Lovelett Present
Kathleen Hawk Present
Larry Ricci Present

 

Also Present: Bonnie Franson of H2M

Chairman Rich Lanzarone called the meeting to order at 7:00 pm with the Pledge of Allegiance.

 

Public Hearings: None

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Old Applications:

 

Applicant Application Location Zoning Dist. SBL Number Status
Novi, John 2 Lot Sub-Division

 

1315 Rte 213 B-1 70.46-2-5.100 Recvd. Application, short EAF deeds, maps 3/18/14

Had Daytime Review 4/2/14

Recvd. Long EAF and revised map 4/4/14

On 4/9/14 agenda

Submitted Lead Agency Request to TB, ZBA, HF Water Dist., NYSOPRHP, UC health Dept., UC Planning Dept. (ZBA response to Lead Agency Request recvd. 4/23/14)no other responses recvd. / Referred to TB for ODA and ZBA for variance(s) (no response)

 

John Novi was present for the meeting.

 

Following discussion, Chairman Lanzarone requests a motion to adopt Lead Agency status on the Novi application.

Upon motion of Member Steve Wood, seconded by Member Kris Lovelett and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

 

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

The Board reviews and discusses the EAF form. The applicant agrees with any changes made to the form.

 

Following the review, Chairman Lanzarone request a motion to issue a Negative Declaration.

Upon motion of Member Todd Natale, seconded by Member Kathy Hawk, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

 

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

The Chairman instructs the Secretary to notify the DEC, Town Board and the ZBA since this is a Type I under SEQRA.

 

New Applications:

Applicant Application Location Zoning Dist. SBL Numbers Status
Somer, Taavo Lot

Line Adjustment

Cooper Street, Accord A-3 69.1-4-22

69.1-4-21.100

69.1-4-50

 

Application submitted on 5/27/14

 

 

Colin Houston of North and Houston Land Surveyors was present to discuss the Somer application.

Applicant Response Board Response Planner Response
Mr. Houston explains what the property owners wish to do.

Currently, there are 3 existing parcels- would like to take the 3 parcels and make it in to 2 parcels-there is no new construction proposed.

To Bonnie- Answers ‘no’

 

Chairman questions which lines will be deleted The middle parcel will be gone.

 

Bonnie explains her review which can be obtained in the Planning Office.

Questions MR. Houston if there are any restrictions on the deed such as Right OF Ways or Easments

 

Chairman Lanzarone requested a motion to classify the Somer application as an Unlisted Action under SEQRA.

Upon motion of Member Steve Wood, seconded by Member Larry Ricci, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

 

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

 

Chairman Lanzarone requested a motion to classify the application as a Lot Line Adjustment.

Upon motion of Member Kris Lovelett, seconded by Member Steve Wood, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

Chairman Lanzarone requested a motion to issue a Negative Declaration under SEQRA for the Somer application.

 

Upon motion of Member Todd Natale, seconded by Member Kathy Hawk, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

 

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

Following review, Chairman Lanzarone requested a motion to adopt the Resolution of approval of the application.

Upon motion of Member Larry Ricci, seconded by Member Todd Natale, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

Discussion: Colleen Bicknese and Stephen Granfield

 

Location Zoning Dist. SBL Numbers Status
Bicknese-159 Stone Dock

Granfield-165 Stone Dock

R-1 Bicknese-69.4-2-10.100

Granfield-69.4-2-11

No application submitted

Discussion at 3/12/14 meeting regarding letter from Colleen

Letter from Stephen submitted 5/16/14

 

 

Colleen Bicknese, Stephen Granfield and Architect Matt Mason were present for the meeting.

The Board and the Planner discuss the Right of Way. Chairman Lanzarone explains that the Planning Board cannot expunge the Right of Way and recommends that they go to the Zoning Board to handle the matter. The Board stated that the minutes will be forwarded and the Board will respond to the letter.

No Official Actions were taken regarding the Bicknese/Granfield discussion

 

Two members of the public were present for the meeting and formally thanked the Board for the way that the Woodman, LLC application was handled. They heard of a possibility of the Rondout Valley Manufacturing parking lot being utilized for school bus parking and questioned whether that will be something that will come in front of the Planning Board.

Chairman Lanzarone explains that in the past, another bus company wanted to rent it out as a bus storage/maintenance facility and historically, the Code Enforcement Officer told them that it is not an allowed use in an industrial zone. The bus company then had a discussion with the ZBA and they did not approve it. He explained that this would not come before the Planning Board; it would go to the Code Enforcement Officer.

 

Action Items:

  1. Review, Approve, Sign off on charges/2 Vouchers from Jacobowitz and Gubits

The Board reviewed the vouchers.

Chairman Lanzarone requested a motion to open an Escrow account for the Jasinski 2-Lot Sub-Division application in the amount of $1,000.00.

Upon motion of Member Steve Wood, seconded by Member Kris Lovelett, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

 

 

  1. Approve Minutes from 4/9/14 and 5/15/14 meeting.

Chairman Lanzarone requested a motion to approve the minutes from 4/9/14.

 

Upon motion of Member Todd Natale, seconded by Member Sylvia Ricci, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

 

Chairman Lanzarone requested a motion to approve the 5/15/14 minutes.

 

Upon motion of Member Kris Lovelett, seconded by Member Kathy Hawk, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

 

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

The Chairman requested a motion to adjourn.

Upon motion of Member Sylvia Ricci, seconded by Member Steve Wood, and the affirmative vote of 7 members, the negative vote of 0 members, the abstention of 0 members, 1 member being absent the motion carries.

 

Vote: All Aye
Kris Lovelett Aye
Richard Lanzarone (Chairman) Aye
Steve Wood Aye
Sylvia Ricci Aye
Kathy Hawk Aye
Mary Collins (Alternate) Absent
Todd Natale Aye

 

 

The meeting was adjourned at 8:40 pm.

 

Respectfully Submitted,

Holly Behnke, Secretary to the Planning Board